[Tileset] soar (Page 1 of 2)

Looks good but I dont like the death tiles (:

Thanks Guys!

@AwayD: Thats really nice of you - Thanks! I didn't even know about that auto-mapping stuff and had to look it up.

Yeaaah.... about this - I reuploaded the tileset to my own webspace because i wanted it to have the name i want it to (which is "soar") and not the name tinypic gave it. (ny..something)

If it's not too much work, could you change the name in the rule-thing? I don't know anything about this stuff, so i can't really do it on my own.

Edit: Thanks!

class!

I find it difficult to see what tile I can stand on and not. And the shadows of the Säulen is strange.

no, that's not nice. This is utter kagg. The perspective is wrong and the colors do not match. Why he does not like gray tiles on the foreground and the background? You can actually see anything.

Well, usually i do not comment on tilesets without being asked, but before the situation escalates and/or a flamewar starts I might throw in my two pennies.

@Benutzername: First of all I have to say that your tileset is nicely done for a first tileset. I always appreciate it when community member get active and try to contribute. And it's really great if there are more community members who like it,too.
@Mr.Mushroom: Please do not be rude, we appreciate fair comments.

This is a (really) quick tileset check:
colors: usually the main tiles are very colorful and the background tiles are desaturated (e.g. grass mains: brown-orange + green; grass background: desaturated dark brown). The unhookables should be even more distinguishable than the other tiles, so that it is really easy to see that these tiles are different. (the current teeworlds unhookables have a colored outline and another inner white outline.)

details: well, the pillars in the background are more detailed than the main tiles, this is exactly the opposite of what the eye expects and what you should do.

gradients: gradients as used at the pillars are a teeish no-go

perspective: the baskets are not drawn in the parallel projection perspective/ full side view. The lid is elliptical, which is only possible if the baskets stand askew.

But thanks for reminding me that I wanted to create a "pimp my style" tutorial for doodads and main tiles.

As soon as i have some more time on my hands, i'll see if i can improve these things. Thanks for your feedback.

Looking forward to seeing it.

Well then you really really suck at expressing yourself.

I'm currently making a map out of this, it looks nice so far since the tilset is awesome !

Very nice, i really like the updated version

hmm, good job

Cute.